| 1911 *W.A. Rushton, Plainfield |
1980 James Little, Beech Grove |
| 1912 *Mont Boord, Covington |
1981 William Welsheimer, South Bend |
| 1913 *B.K. Adams, Peru |
1982 David H. Cook, Brookville |
| 1914 *Ivory C. Tolle, Lebanon |
1983 Michael St. Pierre, CFSP, Indianapolis |
| 1915 *Folger P. Wilson, Richmond |
1984 Ken Grandstaff, Roann |
| 1916 *W.F. Evans, Brownsburg |
1985 Russell B. Johnson, Anderson |
| 1917 *C.R. Wilson, Mooresville |
1986 Michael T. Butts, Terre Haute |
| 1918 *H.P. Martin, Terre Haute |
1987 William B. Scott, Jeffersonville |
| 1919 *Chas C. LaFollete, Thorntown |
1988 Kenneth Parson, Muncie |
| 1920 *James M. Chappell, Kendallville |
1989 *Gerald V. Rees, Hobart |
| 1921 *Clyde E. Titus, Indianapolis |
1990 Richard E. Tudor, Franklin |
| 1922 *J. Frank Hamilton, Westport |
1991 *Maurice L. Sefton, Indianapolis |
| 1923 *Harley E. Hickman, Terre Haute |
1992 Elden B. LaHayne, Hammond |
| 1924 *Floyd E. Williams, Gary |
1993 Leonard Urban, Connersville |
| 1925 *Harry M. Allen, Peru |
1994 John Noffze, Alexandria |
| 1926 *Paul H. Buchanan, Indianapolis |
1995 Dan Frain, Winamac |
| 1927 *Floyd S. Culp, Goshen |
1996 Jerrit Clayton, CFSP, Zionsville |
| 1928 *Frank A. LePell, Valparaiso |
1997 Gary Eastlund, Syracuse |
| 1929 *Charles Herrlich, New Palestine |
1998 Terry Davidson, Delphi |
| 1930 *James A. Coffing, Attica |
1999 Mike Owens, CFSP, Alexandria |
| 1931 *Bert S. Gadd, Indianapolis |
2000 Sam Frain, CFSP, Winamac |
| 1932 *Bert S. Gadd, Indianapolis |
2001 Ron Deremiah, CFSP, Indianapolis |
| 1933 *Bert S. Gadd, Indianapolis |
2002 David McCoy, Hammond |
| 1934 *Hallard A. Flynn, Chesterton |
2003 Brian Vaughan, CFSP, Indianapolis |
| 1935 *Jesse F. Phillippi, Zionsville |
2004 Angela Sallee, CFSP, Indianapolis |
| 1936 *Dwight R. Baker, Dayton |
2005 Timothy Yoder, Goshen |
| 1937 *Dwight R. Baker, Dayton |
2006 Lynn Haverstock, Michigan City |
| 1938 *Herbert R. Wald, Indianapolis |
2007 Darrell Holtzclaw, CFSP, Indianapolis |
| 1939 *Morris H. Sleeth, Shelbyville |
2008 Dr. Charles French, CFSP, Brazil |
| 1940 *Frank M. McNeely, Indianapolis |
2009 Jim Todd, Rushville |
| 1941 *Frank J. Evans, Noblesville |
2010 *Ed Porter, CFSP, Anderson |
| 1942 *Clarence C. Piepho, Muncie |
2011 Paul St. Pierre, Indianapolis |
| 1943 *John H. Blackwell, Indianapolis |
2012 Dan Hurt, Indianapolis |
| 1944 *Harold E. Rozelle, Anderson |
2013 Rick Ferguson, Seymour |
| 1945 *Ralph McMullan, Kempton |
2014 Andy Clayton, Indianapolis |
| 1946 *Ralph McMullan, Kempton |
2015 Alan Earl, Argos |
| 1947 *Donald C. Ulrich, Dillsboro |
2016 Wallace Hooker, Wingate |
| 1948 *Verlan L. Poindexter, Washington |
2017 Scott Stodghill, Fort Branch |
| 1949 *J. Harold Fife, East Chicago |
2018 Norman Juday, LaPorte |
